Author Topic: WBPP and East/West Flats support  (Read 883 times)

Offline PHannah

  • Newcomer
  • Posts: 13
WBPP and East/West Flats support
« on: 2020 January 17 13:06:35 »
I am just trying WBPP for the first time. I have a rotator and have to match E/W flats with E/W light frames, so following Juan's advice from an earlier post I defined new custom Filter groups for each combination, e.g. Red_East for the lights and flats.

I also unchecked Apply in the Integration box to prevent WBPP from integrating East and West separately.

But trying to Run, I immediately had a problem (I expect the same with the old BPP): for one of my filters I only had 2 East light frames so I got an error (Cannot integrate less than 3 Light frames)  - even though I had unchecked Apply Integration. So there is no need for this error when integration is not required.

But the main point is, does this nullify the advantage of WBPP, because the Weighting Presets are only applied during integration? In other words, up to the Register stage is WBPP the same as BPP? If that is the case, I can't see any advantage in using WBPP with E/W flats.

The only solution I can see would be to enhance Image Calibration to read the FITS keyword PIERSIDE and match the Lights to the corresponding Flats. Then there would be no need for these extra filter groups which prevent WBPP running Image Integration.


Offline Juan Conejero

  • PTeam Member
  • PixInsight Jedi Grand Master
  • ********
  • Posts: 7111
    • http://pixinsight.com/
Re: WBPP and East/West Flats support
« Reply #1 on: 2020 January 20 10:05:53 »
Quote
But trying to Run, I immediately had a problem (I expect the same with the old BPP): for one of my filters I only had 2 East light frames so I got an error (Cannot integrate less than 3 Light frames)  - even though I had unchecked Apply Integration. So there is no need for this error when integration is not required.

This bug is now fixed (along with a few more ones) in version 1.4.3 of the WBPP script, which I have just released as an update. Sorry for the inconvenience.

Quote
enhance Image Calibration to read the FITS keyword PIERSIDE and match the Lights to the corresponding Flats.

This would require also a nontrivial modification of the WBPP script. This is in our TODO list, although with low priority because custom filters can perform the same task without problems in the WBPP script (and avoid us a new dependency on nonstandard FITS keywords).
Juan Conejero
PixInsight Development Team
http://pixinsight.com/